The Art of Criticism

Professor Sophie Pinkham

Cornell University
Spring 2024
Designed by Nikhil Chinchalkar

About

Essays

Authors


An Eruption into Pop Culture: Van Halen’s Debut Album

Nathaniel Whittington



Van Halen, the self-titled debut album by the American rock band Van Halen, released in 1978, stands as a landmark in the history of not only rock music but music in general. This album not only redefined the sound of hard rock and music for generations to come but also left an undeniable mark on the music industry with its innovative guitar work, electric live performances, and memorable songs. The band members included the singers David Lee Roth, an energetic singer-showman, and Michael Anthony, a technical bassist with belting backing vocals. Then they also had the two Van Halen Brothers: Alex Van Halen, a heavy-hitting drummer who brought charisma and power from the background, and Eddie Van Halen, the driving factor of the band, the innovative, dedicated, mad-genius on lead guitar. This original band lineup includes a quartet of musicians who, as individuals, were some of the best in their fields but, as a unit, shook the world with their presence. An analytical critique of Van Halen necessitates an exploration of its musical elements, cultural impact, and enduring influence. The album draws from various musical influences, from the bluesy swagger of "Ain't Talkin' 'bout Love" to the pop sensibilities of "Jamie's Cryin'." This expansive yet similar mix of styles helped distinguish Van Halen from their contemporaries and contributed to the album's broad appeal. The album begins with a mysterious rising siren, which segues into a staccato bassline as "Running with the Devil" introduces the band. It opens with a thunderous riff from Eddie Van Halen, followed by David Lee Roth's iconic vocals and mixes of screams and shrieks. This song sets the tone for the entire album with infectious energy, a catchy chorus, and a memorable guitar solo, staples of any Van Halen song. Immediately after the song's conclusion, the pinnacle of guitar shredding, "Eruption," begins.

Eddie Van Halen's innovative tapping and whammy bar techniques revolutionized the way guitarists approached the instrument, and clocking in at just over a minute and a half, "Eruption" showcases Van Halen's technical prowess and virtuosity. This instrumental track is often hailed as one of the greatest guitar solos ever. Just as you start feeling the rhythm and getting a sense of Eddie's rudimentary patterns, he adds new pieces and completely throws any chance of simplicity out the window. The song's climax happens just as Eddie completes an exhilarating trill from the ninth fret, working down to the first, which seems rapid until he begins tapping. This technique, popularized by Eddie, truly paved the way for guitarists to come. It involves the player trilling or rapidly hammering on and off between his pinky and index finger on the left hand and using the right hand to simultaneously press away on the exact string a few frets up. This sound creates a mind-blowing, three-note pattern that optimized not only Eddie's sound but the sound of every major metal group in the 1980s.

Another critical factor that is explicitly obvious in Van Halen is Eddie's use of a new guitar tone that allows a punchy yet refined "brown sound." This unique tone simultaneously seems clear and messy, adding speed and different octaves to Eddie's licks. While the details of the lengths Eddie went to to achieve this sound are clouded in mystery, there are some factors that we can trace. Eddie has long believed in using his guitar pickups and amp to achieve distortion, favoring a natural raw tone over a pedal. This is evident in his war-torn guitar, which resembles something that might come from a junkyard. This masterpiece of functional/playable art, rightly named the "Frankentrat," features a Fender factory defect neck and body, chiseled cavern to fit an oversized Gibson humbucker pickup, which allows the guitar to contain a fuller tone similar to a Les Paul-type guitar, yet the playability of a Stratocaster. The guitar's finishing quality is its chaotic paint job of red, white, and black stripes. This guitar is genuinely as recognizable as its guitarist and is the distinguishing factor of the band's early records. The sound image and design of the guitar are all unique characteristics of the "brown sound" Van Halen is famous for. Eddie plugs the "Frankenstrat" into a Marshall 100W cabinet amplifier and uses a variac transformer to lower the voltage and allow a cleaner distortion evident in songs like "Atomic Punk" and "Little Dreamer." The clarity and raw power of the "brown sound" truly make Van Halen stand out amongst any other album at the time.

Another significant factor that makes Van Halen an exciting and almost futuristic experience every time it's played is its use of guitar effects. The album's fourth track, "Ain't Talkin' 'Bout Love," showcases the use of these effect pedals in an exhilarating and almost immediate fashion. In the wake of the first riff sequence, Eddie turns on his flanger pedal and a rush of electricity bolts through the listener's body. The flanger guitar pedal creates a distinctive swirling, swooshing sound effect that adds depth and movement to the guitar signal. The effect is achieved by duplicating the guitar signal, delaying one copy slightly, and modulating the delay time. This modulation creates peaks and troughs in the frequency spectrum, resulting in a sweeping sound reminiscent of a jet plane flying overhead or the whooshing sound of wind. Additionally, producers incorporated tape echo or analog delay effects to add ambiance and spaciousness to Eddie's guitar tone. This effect provided a subtle yet crucial layer of depth to the sound, particularly during solos and melodic passages. It helped to fill out the sonic spectrum and contribute to the album's rich, dynamic sound.

This album means a lot to me, and beyond its unmistakable quality in the songs and overall production, it contains a particular significance for me and many guitarists worldwide. The first time I had ever heard Van Halen was when the pandemic started, and my friend's dad compared my measly $70 starter electric guitar to the "Frankenstrat" as they weren't the prettiest instruments but still served a purpose. I had been playing guitar for about eight months up to this point, and little did I know that turning on the first song of Van Halen would completely change how I thought about music and, more importantly, how I played guitar. I would turn on the record and spend three hours a day practicing the same track repeatedly, developing my muscle memory and ability to move my hand around the neck until each note combination was perfect. While this may not be everyone's idea of a good time, it is for me. This album was the main reason I ultimately got hooked on my passion for electric guitar. For other guitarists, this album and the band redefined what it meant to be a rockstar, and since then, many acts have tried to copy the band's sound and stage presence. Bands such as Guns N' Roses, Metallica, and Red Hot Chili Pepper have all cited influence from Van Halen, especially their debut album. Slash, the lead guitarist of Guns N' Roses, has cited Eddie Van Halen as one of his biggest influences, and the band's dynamic, riff-heavy rock songs reflect elements of Van Halen's style. Similarly, guitarist John Frusciante has praised Eddie Van Halen's innovative playing style and incorporated his technical elements into his playing, contributing to the band's distinctive sound.

The album is not universally held in such high regard, though, as some critics argue that Van Halen's commercial success and mainstream appeal have overshadowed their musical innovation and artistic merit. While Van Halen is praised for its technical proficiency and energetic performances, some listeners may perceive the band as too commercial or formulaic, particularly compared to more underground or alternative acts. In addition, David Lee Roth's vocals are an anomaly as he doesn't necessarily have the voice of an angel and often relies on his screams and yelling instead of singing. While this may turn off some listeners, it adds to Van Halen's raw and almost punk feel, with David putting his emotions directly into the album. In songs like "On Fire," some of my favorite parts are when Roth belts into these animal screams, as I've never heard anyone hit those high notes, especially those reminiscent of an ancient war battle cry.

Van Halen's debut album is a monumental achievement for both the band and music, showcasing unparalleled technical prowess, innovative guitar work, and unforgettable performances. The quartet of musicians, including David Lee Roth, Michael Anthony, Alex Van Halen, and the visionary Eddie Van Halen, crafted a record that not only redefined the genre but also left an indelible mark on the music industry as a whole. From the infectious energy of "Running with the Devil" to the groundbreaking virtuosity of "Eruption," each track on the album demonstrates the band's unparalleled talent and creativity. Eddie Van Halen's revolutionary guitar techniques, from his groundbreaking tapping to his signature "brown sound," set a new standard for guitarists and reshaped the landscape of rock music for generations to come. Moreover, the album's influence extends beyond its initial release, with countless artists citing Van Halen as a primary inspiration. While some may critique the band's commercial success and call the band sellouts, there's no denying the enduring impact and significance of Van Halen's debut album, which continues to captivate listeners and inspire musicians worldwide. Through its raw emotions, technical brilliance, and timeless appeal, Van Halen's self-titled album remains a testament to the power of innovation and the enduring legacy of one of rock music's greatest pioneers.